Bladensburg cross case. Justice Samuel Alito, writing for the .


  •  Bladensburg cross case. The case was a consolidation of two petitions to the Sep 30, 2025 · WASHINGTON (RNS) — The large historic cross that sits in a Maryland traffic circle is constitutional, the Supreme Court has ruled. But this case does not just have the potential to save this cross, but has the potential to fix a huge problem in establishment clause jurisprudence which has led to far too many lawsuits attacking any religious symbol Nov 20, 2017 · This case does not threaten those religious symbols in any way. Nov 20, 2017 · This case does not threaten those religious symbols in any way. No reasonable observer would conclude that the government is endorsing Christianity just because an individual’s gravestone includes a cross. American Humanist Association, a case in which the justices considered whether or not the display of a World War I memorial cross standing on government owned property in Bladensburg, Maryland violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. Sarah Silbiger/The New York Times Jun 21, 2019 · UVA Law professors recently weighed in on the Bladensburg Peace Cross case, which was at the center of Wednesday’s religious liberty decision at the U. Research Professor of Law, University of Virginia School of Law and Micah Schwartzman Joseph W. Jun 20, 2019 · The AHA Argues at the Supreme Court in Bladensburg Cross Case On February 27, 2019, the American Humanist Association argued in front of the Supreme Court of the United States regarding the unconstitutionality of a 40-foot-tall Christian cross towering over a bustling Bladensburg, Maryland intersection. American Humanist Association), Asim Jusic critiques the endorsement/exclusion theory, which the dissenting justices in this case used to criticize the U. This is the case in which secularists are demanding the removal of a large cross that memorializes veterans in the town of Jun 20, 2019 · The Supreme Court ruled on June 20 that a war memorial in Maryland in the shape of a Christian cross can stay on public land. . Jun 20, 2019 · A World War I memorial cross sits in Bladensburg, Md. This is the case in which secularists are demanding the removal of a large cross that memorializes veterans in the town of Bladensburg, Maryland because the cross resides on public property. American Legion v. S son v. Jun 21, 2019 · UVA Law professors recently weighed in on the Bladensburg Peace Cross case, which was at the center of Wednesday’s religious liberty decision at the U. Sep 25, 2025 · (RNS) - For many court watchers, including BJC, it is difficult to reconcile the promise of religious liberty for all with the constitutionality of a massive Latin cross sponsored by the government. Just outside the Supreme Court, Maryland resident Mike Moore reflected on where he'd be if that cross was never built. The “Peace Cross” was constructed in 1925 in honor of 49 fallen veterans of World Feb 24, 2019 · The Bladensburg Cross case has our country on the verge of abandonment of longstanding and hard won principles about the secular character of American government. The Bladensburg Peace Cross, a commemorative display for local soldiers who died in World War I, stands in isolation at the intersection of a busy highway. Jul 27, 2018 · (Washington, D. The Court ruled that the 40-foot-tall stone and concrete “ Peace Cross ” memorial displayed on government-owned property in Bladensburg, Maryland, outside Washington, D. Jun 20, 2019 · The court voted, 7-2, to reject the challenge to the Peace Cross in Bladensburg. Carter, Jr. It’s crucial to realize that the cross wasn’t erected yesterday. Supreme Court. Myth: The Bladensburg cross was originally placed on private property. There can be no doubt that the Bladensburg cross decision – as narrow as it may have been written – redrew constitutional boundaries when it comes to government-owned religious displays. On this episode, we go inside the courtroom with journalist Tom Strode who gives us a behind-the-scenes look at the case. In a 7-2 decision, the Court ruled that the presence of a large cross on public land does not violate the U. The American Humanist Association had sued the Maryland-National Capital Park and Planning Jun 20, 2019 · The Supreme Court on Thursday said a 40-foot, 16-ton Latin cross war memorial in Bladensburg, Maryland, can stand, upholding the constitutionality of a religious symbol on public land, but Jun 21, 2019 · The court reached the correct result, but the mish-mash of Bladensburg opinions leaves Establishment Clause jurisprudence in a muddled state. SCOTUS can and should step back from the brink. The government sought to maintain the monument, known as the Bladensburg Peace Cross, by distorting its Christian message. Mar 1, 2019 · Division of the citizenry along denominational lines is what’s at stake in the Bladensburg Cross case, and presumably in a range of analogous cases concerning religious expression by the government. Sep 23, 2019 · The case demonstrates how government subverts religion when it tries to use religion for its purposes, and the case answers the false claims that government neutrality toward religion amounts to hostility. In a 7-2 decision, the high court determined Thursday (June 20) that the World War I monument known as the Bladensburg Cross, erected by the American Legion in 1925, does not violate the Constitution’s establishment clause. Mar 8, 2019 · On February 27, 2019, the Supreme Court of the United States heard oral argument in consolidated appeals Nos. The image of the simple wooden cross that originally marked the graves of American soldiers killed in World War I became a symbol of their sacrifice, and the design of the Bladensburg Cross must be understood in light of that background. Nov 6, 2018 · Last Friday, the Supreme Court announced that it will decide whether a governmental display of a gigantic, 40-foot Latin cross as a war memorial in Bladensburg, Maryland, violates the separation of church and state. The Bladensburg Cross does precisely that, because the Latin cross is not only a symbol of Christianity, but the preeminent symbol Feb 26, 2014 · Such is the case with a cross in Bladensburg, Maryland, commonly known as the “Peace Cross,” which stands forty-feet high on a government-owned median between roadways. The federal government asked the Supreme Court to rule in favor of the cross. SCOTUS Seems to Agree. Today, in a 7-2 decision, the Justices of the Supreme Court of the United States preserved the nearly 100-year old Bladensburg WWI Veterans Memorial, along with memorials like it bearing religious symbols across the country. The Town of Bladensburg gave American Legion Post 3 the “care” of the land and the cross after it was erected (but left unfinished in Feb 28, 2019 · A cross commemorating the sacrifice of these soldiers, using a symbol representing…you guessed it, sacrifice, does not establish a religion of Christianity in Bladensburg. Feb 27, 2019 · December 28, 2015 AHA Appeals Lawsuit against Bladensburg Cross Monument May 4, 2015 Humanist Group Files for Summary Judgment in Case Against Bladensburg Cross February 25, 2014 Lawsuit Demands Removal of 40-Foot Christian Cross from Government Property September 5, 2012 Bladensburg Peace Cross Should Come Down, Atheist Group Argues The Peace Cross[1] is a World War I memorial located in Bladensburg, Maryland. The Supreme Court heard oral arguments at the end of February on the Bladensburg cross case, in which the Justices must answer the constitutionality of a war memorial in the shape of a cross seated on government-owned property. , which honors local men who died in World War I, violates the separation of church and state. Jun 20, 2019 · Consistent with the Court’s case law, the Court today applies a history and tradition test in examining and upholding the constitutionality of the Bladensburg Cross. Given spatial constraints, there is no room to add other commemorative displays (religious or secular) in the immediate vicinity of the 32-foot tall Latin cross. Feb 27, 2019 · The Bladensburg cross case tees up the Lemon test for overturning. Andrew and Monica spend the entire show doing a deep Jun 9, 2023 · This week, we celebrate the four-year anniversary of our landmark victory for the Bladensburg Peace Cross. American Humanist Ass’n that the state of Maryland does not violate the Establishment Clause by having the Bladensburg Nov 29, 2018 · Do you believe that the Bladensburg Peace Cross violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. As the Daily Signal described the case: The Supreme Court ruled 7-2 Thursday that a cross-shaped war memorial on public land in Maryland doesn’t violate the Constitution. Justice Alito announced the judgment of the Supreme Court and delivered the opinion of the court with respect to Parts I, II–B, II–C, III, and IV, in which Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Breyer, Kagan Jun 4, 2019 · A veterans memorial located in Bladensburg, Maryland. Apr 25, 2019 · The important case of the Bladensburg Peace Cross was argued before the Supreme Court this term. Construction on the cross began in 1918, and it was widely described using Christian terms and celebrated in Christian services. Nov 2, 2018 · In 2014, the American Humanist Association (AHA) and others filed suit in District Court, alleging that the Cross’s presence on public land and the Commission’s maintenance of the memorial violate the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause. 228, 244 (1982). Feb 4, 2019 · The Town of Bladensburg gave American Legion Post 3 the “care” of the land and the cross after it was erected (but left unfinished in 1922). Feb 24, 2020 · Following the Bladensburg cross case decision, the justices sent the Pensacola case back to the 11th Circuit for reconsideration. , near Washington, and commemorates 49 fallen soldiers from Prince George’s County. Supreme Court decisions we’ll soon hear about is the Bladensburg cross case. Mar 2, 2018 · Thankfully, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, by a 8-6 vote, has agreed that the cross is indeed a Christian symbol. What was the case about? Jun 21, 2019 · The Bladensburg Cross case will change the nomenclature of standards, but will not eliminate case-by-case consideration of the context of displays. Further, the Bladensburg Cross has frequently been used for Christian religious activity. Jun 24, 2019 · The case presented a constitutional challenge to a war memorial on public property in Bladensburg, Maryland—a 32-foot-high Latin cross erected 90 years ago to commemorate county residents who had died in World War I. The June 20 ruling reversed a lower court decision last year. Feb 27, 2019 · WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Wednesday considered the fate of the Bladensburg cross, a 40-foot-tall World War I memorial in Maryland maintained with government funds. 20-acre site at the three-way junction of Bladensburg Road, Baltimore Avenue, and Annapolis Road in Bladensburg, Maryland. The 3rd U. One of the major Supreme Court decisions we’ll soon hear about is the Bladensburg cross case. Jun 20, 2019 · The Supreme Court of the United States in a 7-2 decision held on Thursday that the 40 foot tall Bladensburg Memorial Cross is Constitutional, does not violate the First Amendment's Establishment Claus This is the case in which secularists are demanding the removal of a large cross that memorializes veterans in the town of Bladensburg, Maryland because the cross resides on public property. Jun 22, 2019 · A 40-foot cross in the middle of a Bladensburg intersection survived a court challenge Wednesday, with the majority of the Supreme Court ruling that its age was a factor. This feature of the case makes it difficult to argue for the constitutionality Feb 4, 2019 · This post originally appeared on TheHumanist. The town made clear that the land and the cross would revert back to Bladensburg if Post 3 disbanded. Aug 23, 2019 · This memorial has become known as the Bladensburg Cross. From First Liberty: Is a 100-year-old WWI Veterans Jun 20, 2019 · In a 7–2 decision, the Supreme Court ruled on Thursday that a giant memorial cross on public land in Maryland can stay there. News4’s Jun 20, 2019 · Today, by a 7-2 vote, the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the Bladensburg Peace Cross. "When I It is located on a 0. Protesters both for and against the removal of the World War I memorial Peace Cross in Bladensburg, Maryland, gathered at the Supreme Court Wednesday to hear arguments for the case. The case was a consolidation of two petitions to the court, that of The American Legion who built the cross (Docket 17–1717), and of the Maryland-National Capital Park and Planning Commission who own the land and maintain the memorial (Docket 18-18). , does not violate the Establishment Clause. Applying these principles, to the facts of this case, the Supreme Court held the Bladensburg Cross did not violate the Establishment Clause. December 28, 2015 AHA Appeals Lawsuit against Bladensburg Cross Monument May 4, 2015 Humanist Group Files for Summary Judgment in Case Against Bladensburg Cross February 25, 2014 Lawsuit Demands Removal of 40-Foot Christian Cross from Government Property September 5, 2012 Bladensburg Peace Cross Should Come Down, Atheist Group Argues Jun 21, 2019 · Thursday morning, the Supreme Court ruled 7–2 in American Legion v. Feb 27, 2019 · (For context, Neal Katyal represents the Maryland-National Capital Park and Planning Commission, Michael Carvin represents the American Legion, and Jeffrey Wall represents the United States, all of whom argue that the Bladensburg Cross in this case is constitutional. Jun 20, 2019 · The Supreme Court ruled today on American Legion v. One takeaway from this case could be that an unconstitutional establishment can become permissible if it stays up long enough without objection. In a victory for religious freedom, the Supreme Court allowed the Bladensburg Cross to stand in Maryland. Washington, D. Judgment: Reversed and remanded, 7-2, in an opinion by Justice Alito on June 20, 2019. In 2017, a federal appeals court ruled that the cross violated the First Amendment's Establishment Clause under the so-called "endorsement test. With a 7-2 decision, the Court upheld the Jul 8, 2019 · Today's episode welcomes Monica Miller, counsel for the American Humanist Association, back to the show! Miller, as you know, was the lead counsel and presented the AHA's argument before the Supreme Court in the American Legion v. Nov 2, 2018 · The Supreme Court will hear arguments in a highly publicized case from Maryland about the possible demolition of a memorial cross monument on public property. Dorn Research Professor of Law, University of Virginia School of Law Jun 20, 2019 · The monument, known as the Peace Cross, sits at a busy intersection in Bladensburg, Md. In addition to the obvious sectarian nature of the Latin cross, the Bladensburg cross was also erected with religious motives. View Bladensburg Cross Case: Legal Battle Over a Historic Memorial from BUS 9890 at College of Southern Maryland. Jun 4, 2019 · One of the major U. Jul 23, 2025 · Bladensburg Cross Ruling Supreme Court Upholds Constitutionality of Bladensburg Cross Overview of the Case A high-profile legal case concerning a nearly 100-year-old war memorial was recently resolved by the United States Supreme Court. Fact: The cross was built on the Town of Bladensburg’s land with the approval and involvement of the town’s commissioners in 1919. 3. Nov 12, 2018 · Listen to this article A federal appeals court says the fate of a Pennsylvania county seal containing a cross symbol is on hold pending resolution of a similar case in Maryland. com. 1. Jun 20, 2019 · The Bladensburg cross is, indisputably, a symbol of Christianity. 17-1717 and 18-18, involving the Town of Bladensburg World War I Memorial in the shape of a Celtic-style Latin cross said to be in violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. , July 27, 2018)—The American Humanist Association (AHA) filed its brief in the United States Supreme Court opposing the American Legion’s Petition for Writ of Certiorari in the Bladensburg Cross case. Standing 40 feet (12 m) in height, the large cross is made of tan concrete with exposed pink granite aggregate; the arms of the cross are supported by unadorned concrete arches. That’s not the case, however, with the 40-foot Bladensburg Cross standing alone in the middle of a busy intersection. Banks Nov 20, 2017 · The Bladensburg Cross is not just “cross-shaped” – it is a 40-foot Christian cross! Federal courts have uniformly recognized that a Christian cross (sometimes called a Latin cross) is sectarian and the preeminent symbol of Christianity. In 2014, the American Humanist Association and others filed suit in the District Court, alleging that the cross's presence on public land and the public maintenance of the memorial violated the First Amendment's Establishment Clause. , just outside Washington, D. This decision carries important Feb 24, 2019 · The justices will hear arguments this week about whether the cross in Bladensburg, Md. For more on this case, click here. | (Photo: Liberty Institute) Editor’s note: A version of this article first appeared at The American Spectator. Jun 4, 2019 · This is the case in which secularists are demanding the removal of a large cross that memorializes veterans in the town of Bladensburg, Maryland because the cross resides on public property. Jun 26, 2019 · The case presented a constitutional challenge to a war memorial on public property in Bladensburg, Maryland—a 32-foot-high Latin cross erected 90 years ago to commemorate county residents who had died in World War I. For more podcasts from the Baptist Joint Committee, visit our podcast page or subscribe to our iTunes channel. Project I- Bladensburg Cross Case Alisha Green In 1918 the residents of Prince G. Jul 16, 2018 · Holding: The Bladensburg Cross does not violate the establishment clause of the First Amendment. , northeast of Washington. Nov 6, 2018 · The case could drastically alter longstanding precedent protecting the separation of church and state and send a devastating message to non-Christians Last Friday, the Supreme Court announced that it will decide whether a state government’s display of a gigantic, 40-foot Latin cross as a war memorial in Bladensburg, Maryland, violates the separation of church and state. Jun 20, 2019 · The question before the justices in the Bladensburg Cross case is much simpler than the complex questions Christians face living as principled pluralists in a diverse society. 29 (2019), was a United States Supreme Court case dealing with the separation of church and state related to maintaining the Peace Cross, a World War I memorial shaped after a Latin cross, on government-owned land, though initially built in 1925 with private funds on private lands. In 2019, the US Supreme court ruled in a landmark case that the memorial – known locally as the Peace Cross – could remain M-NCPPC property. RNS photo by Adelle M. C. Despite the sadly predictable result in the Bladensburg Cross case, at least seven justices continue to pay tribute to themes of religious egalitarianism and pluralism. Jun 20, 2019 · By a vote of 7 to 2, the Supreme Court ruled today in American Legion v. Supreme Court in the case. Supreme Court's final decision. The American Legion intervened to defend the Cross. American Humanist Association, 588 U. Jun 24, 2019 · The Establishment Clause and Free Exercise Equality: In Bladensburg Cross Case, the High Court Partially Restores Founders’ View June 24, 2019 May 23, 2025 · A century later, the Bladensburg WWI Veterans Memorial remains standing as a visible reminder of military heroes. The Bladensburg Peace Cross is a 40-foot cross erected as a memorial Sep 1, 2019 · Specifically, the Court acknowledged the trend has been to find constitutional “categories of monuments, symbols, and practices with a longstanding history” and cultural tradition. Jun 24, 2019 · The 40-foot Bladensburg Peace Cross stands on a government-owned intersection in Bladensburg, Md. On June 20, 2019, a Supreme Court decision ushered in a new era for religious freedom and public religious displays. Schragger Perre Bowen Professor of Law and Joseph C. (c) Applying these principles here, the Bladensburg Cross does not violate the Establishment Clause. And why should We The People listeners care about this case? Miller: [00:54:44] Sure, the Bladensburg cross, the 40 foot Latin cross that towers over the busiest intersection in Prince Georges County, clearly violates the Establishment Clause. In 2014, the American Humanist Association (AHA) and others filed suit in District Court, alleging that the Cross’s presence on pub-lic land and the Commission’s maintenance of the memorial violate the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause. American Humanist Ass’n case involving the 40-foot Latin cross on public property in Bladensburg, Maryland. Nov 12, 2018 · A federal appeals court says the fate of a Pennsylvania county seal containing a cross symbol is on hold pending resolution of a similar case in Maryland. Jun 20, 2019 · In Bladensburg, Maryland, as part of a memorial park honoring veterans is a 40-foot tall cross, which is the subject of this litigation. The Bladensburg Cross, which stands at the center of an intersection, was erected between 1919 and 1925 in memory of soldiers from Prince George’s County who died in World War I. 2. American Humanist Association that a 100-year-old World War I memorial cross in Bladensburg, Maryland, doesn’t “establish Jun 3, 2019 · This is the case in which secularists are demanding the removal of a large cross that memorializes veterans in the town of Bladensburg, Maryland because the cross resides on public property. Nov 20, 2017 · The latest legal action in our case against a large Christian cross on government property in Bladensburg, MD. Trump Thinks He’s Found a Way Around a Clear Constitutional Limit. Supreme Court ruled in favor of preserving a historic cross-shaped memorial in Bladensburg, Maryland saying the cross did not endorse religion. S. Jun 21, 2019 · Seven justices voted to reverse, so the Bladensburg Cross will remain in place. Supreme Court agreed to hear a case to decide the fate of a 40-foot cross that sits in the median of a Bladensburg, Feb 18, 2019 · In what is the most important Establishment Clause case at least since Greece — and quite possibly longer — it is deeply imperative that the Court vindicate Judge Gregory’s dissenting opinion of the Fourth Circuit panel below and uphold the constitutionality of the Peace Cross. Establishment Clause Inversion in the Bladensburg Cross Case Richard C. BLADENSBURG CROSS CASE In Bladensburg, Maryland, as part of a memorial park honoring veterans is a 40-foot tall cross, which is the subject of this litigation. On the. They voted to leave in place a ruling that the Bladensburg Memorial cross is unlawful. Dec 12, 2018 · Unlike President Trump’s travel ban, which the Supreme Court upheld last year despite its clear intent to target Muslims, the Bladensburg Cross case does not arise in the immigration or national-security contexts, in which the court has traditionally given more deference to the government. Justice Samuel Alito, writing for the Jun 21, 2019 · American Humanist Association —also known as the Bladensburg Cross case. Constitution. On the surface, the case appears to be about one religious monument located at one Jun 20, 2019 · WASHINGTON — In a 7-2 vote, the U. Feb 27, 2019 · The 40-foot cross at issue in the Supreme Court case honors soldiers from World War I and stands at a busy intersection in Bladensburg, Md. BJC Executive Director Amanda Tyler and General Counsel Holly Hollman discuss the case of The American Legion v. American Humanist Association, and the BJC’s amicus brief filed with the U. Jun 25, 2019 · Denying that forced extractions is a form of government coercion is madness enough, but the outright hostility shown by the Court to the objections of non-believers promises great trouble ahead. Valente, 456 U. But the case produced six separate opinions, and it reveals that the court remains starkly divided on fundamental questions about the meaning of the establishment clause. Aug 23, 2019 · In this reflection on the 2019 Bladensburg Cross case (American Legion v. " A reasonable observer, the Jan 31, 2019 · A Muslim advocacy group is urging the Supreme Court to protect a church-state divide in regards to the Bladensburg Cross, a 40-foot monument at an intersection in a Maryland suburb. Jun 20, 2019 · The Supreme Court said on Thursday that a 40-foot cross on public land in Maryland that was built to honor fallen soldiers in World War I does not violate the separation between church and state Jun 3, 2019 · This is the case in which secularists are demanding the removal of a large cross that memorializes veterans in the town of Bladensburg, Maryland because the cross resides on public property. Nov 12, 2018 · On Friday, November 2, the U. Speaking for the majority of the Court, Justice Alito eloquently wrote: The cross is undoubtedly a Christian symbol, but that fact should not blind us to everything else that the Bladensburg Cross . “Although the cross has long been a preeminent Christian symbol, its use in the Bladensburg […] Nov 3, 2018 · The Supreme Court agreed Friday to hear a case about whether a nearly 100-year-old, cross-shaped war memorial located on a Maryland highway median violates the Constitution's required separation Feb 26, 2019 · A majority of the Supreme Court on Wednesday seemed to be searching for a way — a narrow one, most likely — to allow the Bladensburg Peace Cross commemorating World War I dead to remain where The Bladensburg Cross case has our country on the verge of abandonment of longstanding and hard won principles about the secular character of American government. Dec 9, 2016 · A popular meme about the Bladensburg Cross claimed that "liberals" were "offended" by the WWI memorial and demanded its removal. v4 ltvdaw fnnk u0hdqj 1qq 0g gbip7 uztj vb0g kvqcp
Top