Homeric scholia. The subject is one of the oldest in education.

Homeric scholia. The Venetus A manuscript (Marciana 822 = Graecus Z. Leipzig: Teubner. Ideally, such a text would encompass the full historical reality of the Homeric […] Apr 26, 2022 · At points, then, the scholia are a little pedestrian and can get stuck “in the weeds” of Homeric minutiae that we find easy to dismiss. This book contains a collection of twenty-one essays in honour of Professor Franco Montanari by eminent specialists on Homer, ancient Homeric scholarship, and the reception of the Homeric Epics in both ancient and modern times. Phillips. Odyssey, Homer, Homer Odyssey. -- Scholia, Odyssey (Homer) Publisher Oxonii : E Typographeo Academico Collection americana Book from the collections of University of California Language Ancient Greek; Latin Item Size 599. We two recently published a volume of essays and commentary on Iliad 10 that evolved out of our work on the Multitext. 3710 65 Observations on Περί έπιρρημάτων by Apollonius Dyscolus 87 May 23, 2021 · Scholia are grammatical, critical, or explanatory comments — original or copied from prior commentaries — which are inserted in the margin of the manuscript of ancient authors, as glosses. On occasion, however, the scholia can make genuinely surprising and enlightening points on Homer’s poetic craft; I have learned more than I care to admit from reading them. iliad Learn Homeric scholarship facts for kidsOver time, when people copied these old books, they also copied the scholia. Scholia grouped by page zone For each page, scholia are grouped by the zone they belong to: main The Homer Multitext project is filling this gap. May 7, 2020 · x, 144 pages ; 22 cm The author examines the "Aeneid" in the light of the ancient commentaries, or scholia, on parallel passages in the "Iliad" and "Odyssey". Hellenistic Scholarship and the Study of Language 17 The Greek Origins of the Romans and the Roman Origins of Homer in the Homeric Scholia and in POxy. The A scholia, for which Venetus A is by far the most important source, derive from the so-called "VMK Apr 26, 2014 · The most famous Greek manuscript of the Homeric Iliad, Venetus A (Marcianus Graecus Z. Despite uncertainties about his authorship, Homer is considered one of the most influential authors in history. com. The Homeric scholia form the largest and most impressive monument of ancient and Byzantine literary criticism and textual scholarship, and embody, in however fragmentary and haphazard The ancient scholia to the Iliad —excerpts of ancient scholarship and commentary on the Iliad that have been preserved as marginal and interlinear notes in major medieval manuscripts—constitute a uniquely rich and challenging source for anyone interested in Greco-Roman antiquity. The dramatist regards an epic passage as the reference text, but fails to understand its wording correctly: therefore Sep 9, 2019 · Homeric Scholia Explain the Eminently Explicable September 9, 2019 ~ sententiaeantiquae Jul 8, 2009 · Scholia Graeca in Homeri Iliadem : ex codicibus aucta et emendata by Dindorf, Wilhelm, 1802-1883; Maass, Ernst, 1856-1929 Publication date 1875 Topics Homer, Homer Publisher Oxonii : E Typographeo Clarendoniano Collection americana Book from the collections of New York Public Library Language Ancient Greek; Latin Item Size 685. When the copyist ran out of free text space, he listed them on separate pages or in separate works. In this paper I demonstrate that ancient scholarship on Homer (preserved as scholia to the Iliad) was on the whole very attentive to time in the Iliad, and I outline their methods for resolving perceived problems in the poem’s depiction of time. They are prompted by a unique moment in the history of the Homer Multitext project: we now have a complete first text of the Venetus A manuscript’s Iliad text and scholia, and are beginning to edit further early MSS with extensive scholia to the Iliad. The text is an important source for fragments of otherwise lost works of ancient literature, for the history of exegesis and lexicography, and for Byzantine cultural history. Ancient scholars commented on the Homeric poems in the form of "scholia" that circulated at first within the margins of the text and later as separately published compilations. Our series, The Ancient Scholia to Homer’s Iliad: A Translation, of which my book is the first installment, provides the first English translation of this remarkable collection, making this ancient treasure available to modern readers for the first time. The tomb of Achilles and the topography of the Troad II§42 The Aeolians had their own motives for claiming the territory of Sigeion as their very own Iliadic space. Vols. ; 144 pages; Examines the Aeneid in the light of ancient commentaries, or scholia, on parallel passages in the Iliad and Odyssey. 16 Mk. The identity of E. The Achaean Wall troubled Homer’s ancient readers from Thucydides to the Homeric scholia and later antiquity, just as it has troubled his modern readers. Some are interlinear, written in very small characters. It is currently part of the academic dis 3. Edited by Janus Lascaris [DIDYMUS OF ALEXANDRIA] on Amazon. [3] […] Literary Interpretation in the Homeric Scholia: The Similes of the Iliad. Today, we have footnotes or endnotes in books, which are a lot like these ancient scholia. 3710”, 65-86), Paola Ascheri looks at the Homeric Scholia and P. [3] Because each scholion is indexed to visual evidence and its location on a page, our analysis can combine the textual content of the scholia with information about their layout, and Questions related to the point of view within a narrative text are nowadays discussed under the narratological rubric of focalization. It includes the examination of scholia, ancient commentaries that provide insights into the texts, and has evolved through various editions and interpretations over the centuries. The subject is one of the oldest in education. 03KB Format: PDF View/ Open Classical Studies, Department of Show simple item record 1. The Quest for a Definitive Text of Homer: Evidence from the Homeric Scholia and Beyond* 1§1 As of this writing, Homeric scholarship has not yet succeeded in achieving a definitive text of either the Iliad or the Odyssey. We also have the "E. If there wasn't enough space, they'd put the notes on separate pages. 5M. I argue that Sparta, after expelling a surviving Pylian population from the Peloponnesos In the scholia associated with Aristarchus, a theory of Homer’s identity is employed to decide which parts of the Iliad are authentically Homeric and to explain problems in the interpretation of Homer. Study of the Homeric scholia has recently shifted from purely textual matters to their use in reconstructing lost chapters in the history of ancient literary criticism (Dickie 19-20). Pontani sets out to surpass his predecessors in his understanding of the whole tradition of Homeric interpretation from antiquity through the Byzantine period (not only the scholia themselves and their manuscript tradition, but parallel passages from other sources, which are carefully collected; the collection of scholia aims to be May 26, 2018 · The scholia of Homer’s Iliad are marginal, interlinear annotations that accompany the text in medieval manuscripts. As a result, the task of tracing their contents to their sources is extraordinarily difficult and obscure. Monro, Commentary on the Odyssey (1886). has never been definitively settled, but many scholars think it was either Spenser Apr 22, 2010 · “The Iliad and the First Nine Years the Trojan War,” Swarthmore College “Mind the Gaps: Translating the Scholia to the Iliad,” Università di Genova “Reassessing the Evidence for the ‘Cretan Odyssey,’” Oxford University “The Use and Abuse of Homeric Scholia,” American School of Classical Studies at Athens “Lost in the Middle: Story Time and Discourse Time in the Iliad The Homer Multitext project Downloadable texts HMT editions of texts of the Iliad and scholia of the Venetus A manuscript Facsimile editions Find pages in an illustrated digital edition of the Venetus A manuscript by Iliad line reference Explore the contents of the HMT archive alpha-search: simple alphabetic search of Greek texts in the HMT archive. Apr 2, 2015 · Psychoanalytic Scholia on the Homeric Epics by Konstantinos I Arvanitakis This work attempts a psychoanalytic listening to the ‘oral’ Homeric epics in an effort to extract, as it were, from the ancient text certain elements of psychoanalytic understanding that are of relevance to contemporary psychoanalysis. The translation of Homeric words into their classical or koine equivalents was a Homeric Scholarship Efforts to determine the origins of the Homeric epics, produce an authoritative text, and provide explanatory notes for readers began in antiquity. Filter by manuscript and/or text. However, we certainly welcome discussions of ancient Greek culture, history, and mythology, so long as they pertain to their reflection in an ancient Greek linguistic context. In philological studies of the nineteenth and tw Correcting a Copy, Editing a Text. Kenneth Snipes - 1988 - American Journal of Philology 109 (2). . 1, is forthcoming with Cambridge University Press. The practice of compiling scholia In 2021, I co-edited The Ancient Scholia to Homer’s Iliad: Exegesis and Interpretation (Oxford), and my translation of the scholia to the first two books of the Iliad, The Ancient Scholia to Homer’s Iliad: A Translation, vol. The debate continues to this day (Nagy 2004, 3–24). 2 Like other scholars studying this lost work, I do rely on them. (Co-editor with O. K. There are about 1,800 copies of the Scholars divide Homeric scholia into two main categories, scholia minora and scholia maiora. Greg Nagy’s work on Homeric poetry, combined with his openness to and advocacy of new forms of media for presenting that work, is in multiple ways the foundation on which the Homer Multitext project is built. Homeric scholarship is the study of any Homeric topic, especially the two large surviving epics, the Iliad and Odyssey. This means that commentators interpreted the works of other authors not only by the help of Homer himself, but also by the help of his own coterie of Feb 25, 2019 · The so-called “D” Scholia come from an ancient schoolbook tradition, and largely consist of glosses on Homer. Despite extensive research, a definitive edition of either epic has yet to be This subreddit is dedicated to discussions about ancient Greek language and literature. By Marco Comunetti* This paper analyses two exegetical strategies adopted by ancient scholars to explain Euripides’ mythological innovations and variations with respect to Homer through a selection of scholia. The Ancient Scholia to Homer’s Iliad by Bill Beck He takes the position that ancient variants reported in the Homeric scholia are usually 'suggestions' of ancient scholars (for example Zenodotus) 'towards the improvement of the text, or deliberations about it', and that they are therefore of little significance when constituting the text. " annotations for Spenser's Shepheardes Calender. The examination reveals Vergil's indebtedness to his literary heritage and affords new insights into the purpose and technique of his adaptation and variation of Homeric themes. - Volume 5 Issue 9 The Homeric Question in the Sixteenth Century: Early Modern Scholarship and the Text of Homer* - Volume 68 Issue 2 The general topic of this paper is the reception of the Homeric poems in mainland Greece after their substantial formation in Ionia in the late eighth and early seventh centuries BC. As Severyns demonstrates, the use of this term neōteroi in the Homeric scholia, especially in the scholia for the tenth century codex Venetus A, reflects the usage of Aristarchus himself, not only of the Aristarcheans who came after him—or of the scholiasts who report on the opinions of the Aristarcheans, as in the Venetus A. The study emphasizes two main scholarly groups within the scholia 1§2 The relevance of the scholia (plural of scholion), that is, of annotations that accompany the text of Homer in a wide variety of manuscripts, was first made manifest to the world of modern Homeric scholarship in 1788, when Jean Baptiste Gaspard d’Ansse de Villoison published the tenth-century Venetus A codex manuscript of the Iliad of Homer (codex Marcianus 454). They also represent a striking example of ancient reception and commentary, inherited from the Alexandrians (third to second century BC) and their successors, thus Ernst Maass, Scholia Graeca in Homeri Iliadem Townleyana (1887), a collection of scholia of Homer 's Iliad Ancient scholia are important sources of information about many aspects of the ancient world, especially ancient literary history. The only body of scholia that has been given a modern translation, as far as I know, is the Hesiod scholia, which are included in Cesare Cassanmagnago's 2009 edition of Hesiod, with the Greek and an Italian translation. I focus here on the scholia that reflect the hupomnēmata or commentaries of Aristarchus on the textual transmission of the Homeric Iliad and Odyssey. Homeric Scholia Porphyrii Quaestionum Homericarum ad Odysseam pertinentium reliquias collegit, disposuit, edidit Hermannus Schrader. Texts are available as plain-text files, files in Markdown format, and PDFs. Apr 18, 2008 · Book digitized by Google from the library of Harvard University and uploaded to the Internet Archive by user tpb. It is currently part of the academic discipline of classical studies. 454) Complete texts of the HMT project edition of the Iliad and scholia (pages 12 recto - 326 verso). Summary The essay serves as a general introduction to Homeric scholia. They form a huge corpus of unparalleled richness and preserve significant information on the Homeric text. Feb 22, 2020 · For an introduction to scholia, see Dickey 2007, 11‒16 (on “scholia” as genre) and 18‒23 (on Homeric scholia). WordHoard does not replicate all functionalities of the Chicago Homer but has some features of its own, notably the simultaneous display of all forms of a given lemma, a metrically parsed version of the text, and display of the scholia adjacent to the text. It is an opportune both to The Iliad Scholia and E. But, get this, the ancient scholia are pretty awful too! In a recent article, Sarah Scullin collects misandrist myths and topics from Greece and Rome. [Homeric Scholia on the Iliad] Homeri interpres pervetustus, in Greek. We invite discussion about topics as diverse as Homeric poetry, papyrology Aug 12, 2021 · The ancient scholia to the Iliad—excerpts of ancient scholarship and commentary on the Iliad that have been preserved as marginal and interlinear notes in Homeric scholarship is the study of any Homeric topic, especially the two large surviving epics, the Iliad and Odyssey. The term marginalia includes them. Walter Merry, James Riddell, D. [REVIEW]W. 252 and to Feb 22, 2020 · The Cambridge Guide to Homer - March 2020The essay serves as a general introduction to Homeric scholia. K. 3710, a commentary on Odyssey 20, dating to the second century CE, in order to examine the nature of the idea circulating from the third The work of Aristarchus survives only indirectly, through the reportage of various ancient sources preserved mostly in scholia or notes found in ancient papyrus fragments and in medieval codices. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. [2] Multiformity, according to Lord, is a basic feature of oral traditional poetry. the 8th century BC) was an ancient Greek poet who is credited as the author of the Iliad and the Odyssey, two epic poems that are foundational works of ancient Greek literature. The works of Homer have been heavily annotated since antiquity. I think it unlikely that a translation of the Homer scholia into a modern language will ever exist. The earliest scholia, usually anonymous, date to the 5th or 4th century BC (such as the scholia minora to the Iliad). 7M Homeric scholarship focuses on the study of Homer's epics, the Iliad and Odyssey, and has a rich history dating back to ancient times. Erbse’s edition of the Iliad scholia is certainly a stupendous model of meticulous scholarship. Jan 1, 1974 · The Homeric scholia and the Aeneid: A study of the influence of ancient Homeric literary criticism on Vergil [Schlunk, Robin R] on Amazon. 5M Homeric Scholia - Porphyrii Quaestionum Homericarum ad Odysseam pertinentium reliquias collegit, disposuit, ediditHermannus Schrader. This completed edition of 7 volumes presents a collection of commentaries from Antiquity on Homer's Iliad from the 3rd century BC onwards. Erbse's Scholia Graeca in Homeri Iliadem implemented as annotations attached to lines of The Iliad. This essay is an attempt to explain a set of Homeric scholia that attribute to Aristotle a surprising claim about the eagle in Iliad 21. [1] Papyrus Oxyrhynchus 221, showing scholia from Iliad XXI 'QUARRELSOME' COLLEAGUES Philo of Alexandria provides important, yet hitherto overlooked, evidence concern- ing the relationship between Homeric scholarship and Bible exegesis. [1] In using Jan 1, 2003 · Abstract Questions related to the point of view within a narrative text are nowadays discussed under the narratological rubric of focalization. ) In preparation for Cambridge University Oct 1, 2021 · Holy Cross undergraduates use natural language processing and word embedding to determine that Homeric Scholia are an unrooted network. It covers a wide range of important subjects, including neoanalysis and oral poetry, the Doloneia, the Homeric scholia, the theoretical premises of Aristarchean Oct 2, 2008 · Favorite Scholia Græca in Homeri Odysseam by Wilhelm Dindorf , Homer Publication date 1855 Publisher e typographeo academico Collection europeanlibraries Book from the collections of Oxford University Language Ancient Greek Volume 1 Item Size 100. [1] Aug 6, 2020 · Scholars divide Homeric scholia into two main categories, scholia minora and scholia maiora. The study of the Iliadic scholia is a significant, ongoing area of research in Homeric scholarship. The Homeric scholia to the Iliad are a corpus of commentaries found in the marginalia of the manuscripts of the poem, and, for the most part, they are the last remains of the work elaborated in the library of Alexandria. Homer's poems have always had many notes written about them, right from the start. The Cambridge Guide to Homer examines the influence and meaning of Homeric poetry from its earliest form as ancient Greek song to its current status In preparation. But despite their value, it is important to recognize their limitations. 4§68 Having examined the evidence of the Homeric scholia concerning the criteria of Aristarchus and Didymus, let us return one last time to the wording of scholia A at Iliad I 423–424, οὕτως δὲ εὕρομεν καὶ ἐν τῇ Μασσαλιωτικῇ καὶ Σινωπικῇ καὶ Κυπρίᾳ καὶ 2. The tomb of the hero Achilles was understood to be located in Aeolian territory, […] DJ has light scuffing. ) In preparation for Cambridge University Press. 6-7 the indexes and addenda. On the other hand, its six volumes of some 3,000 pages and voluminous footnotes complete with Latin introduction address themselves to an audience that is now even smaller than it was thirty years ago ( and it was pretty small then): an THE CAMBRIDGE GUIDE TO HOMER From its ancient incarnation as a song to recent translations in modern languages, Homeric epic remains an abiding source of inspiration for both scholars and artists that transcends temporal and linguistic boundaries. Then, in a later section (“Homeric scholia, a window onto the tradition”), we will provide an example from the scholia of the Venetus A manuscript. Posts may involve every dialect of ancient Greek. [1] The Chapter 7 Homer as “Scripture” Let us turn to the last of the five periods in the history of Homeric transmission, as formulated at the beginning of the fifth chapter. The Homeric Text and Problems of Multiformity* 2§1 The multiformity of Homeric poetry is a sign of its prehistory as oral traditional poetry. Their interpretations not only Encouraged by this effort I turned to the scholia. It discusses the different types of Homeric scholia, their content and in which manuscripts they can be found. The Ancient Scholia to Homer’s Iliad: A Translation, Volume 3, Books 7–9. Alexandrian Ekdosis and Papyri 1 Pioneers of Grammar. This insight stems from the work of Milman Parry [1] and Albert Lord. Mar 3, 2012 · Recently I have been using the commentary on the Odyssey available at Perseus - W. These are not available in English translation, but can be very valuable for reading while staying “in language,” as often these scholia will give an expanded Greek explanation for a confusing bit of Homeric Greek. The Ancient Scholia to Homer’s Iliad: A Translation, Volume 2, Books 3–6. The scholia therefore provide us with an otherwise inaccessible view of how the Homeric poems were read and understood in antiquity while at the same time preserving a great deal of historical information about alternate versions of the text. With roots in the Homeric scholarship produced in the Library of Alexandria in the third and second centuries bce, the ancient scholia to the Iliad constitute the richest and most extensive collection of ancient criticism on the most widely read poem in Greco-Roman antiquity. Jan 1, 2020 · The essay serves as a general introduction to Homeric scholia. 454 [=822]), is regarded by some as the best text of the epic poem. Even in Archaic times in Greece, Homer's Iliad had canonical status. The central concept Melanchthon drew from the ancient scholia was οἰκονομία or arrangement, which he sometimes transliterated oeconomia and other times called by its Latin name Original comments are blended with extracts from earlier commentators, especially the Homeric scholia. Ancients and moderns alike have been drawn to the incongruousness of the detail, both its tardiness in the plot but also the very fact of the wall itself, which is disorienting in the extreme. Editing the Homeric Text: West’s Iliad* 3§1 Martin West’s edition of the Homeric Iliad (volume 1 / 1998; volume 2 / 2000) is not, and cannot be, the last word. Still, it serves its purpose in presenting a reconstruction of what one man deems to be the definitive text. Downloadable texts Texts are grouped by manuscript page. Excerpted from lost works of ancient scholarship and transmitted as marginal and interlinear comments in medieval ‘I WILL SEND HIM TO CRETE, AND SANDY PYL FRAGMENT OF THE CYPRIA IN THE HOMERIC SCHOLIA? IN THE HOMERIC SCHO Eugene, Oregon, USA 211 201-2 ISSN ISSN 0065-1141 0065-1141 Mar 31, 2020 · It is probably not surprising to hear that the Homeric poems express misogynistic ideology; even the ancient poet Palladas recognized that Homer was something of a misogynist. 1890. An examination of pertinent Homeric scholia shows that ancient literary critics regularly treated questions of focalization, although they neither had a specific The Commentary collects material from a wide range of different sources which explain or expand on words, phrases and ideas in the Homeric epic. B. While rejecting critical inquiries into Scripture, he offers crucial glimpses into a now lost world Chapter Seven: Conflicting claims on Homer II 7ⓢ1. It highlights the transition from scroll to codex format and the resulting implications for the preservation of Hellenistic commentaries in medieval manuscripts. An examination of pertinent Homeric scholia shows that ancient literary critics regularly treated questions of focalization, although they neither had a specific term for the concept nor discussed it in its own right. The examination reveals Vergil's indebtedness to his literary heritage and affords new insights into the purpose and technique of his adaptation and variation of Homeric themes Includes bibliographical references (pages 139-142) Vergil These notes are a highly personal perspective on what we know about scholia to the Iliad in the summer of 2018. Reading some ancient… Jul 23, 2025 · The Homeric Scholia and the Aeneid Hardcover Robin R. The occupation with this work started at a very early stage, and was of far-reaching significance. Thomas and T. The scholia minora are mainly lexicographical notes aimed at translating difficult Homeric words into koine Greek in the order in which they appear in the text (unlike lexica, which present words in alphabetical order). Within our discussions of these examples, we will continue to consider multiforms and scribal choices and errors. A mass of material that includes textual criticism, lexical debate, and literary interpretation, the scholia Jun 3, 2025 · View Item Show simple item record Homeric Scholia Files in this item Name: 06_homeric_scholia. " These are thought to preserve editorial comments made by scholars at the Royal Library of Alexandria, as well as scholia accumulated by late In this paper I demonstrate that the Homeric scholia fill this Aristotelian vacuum by systematically applying a type of intellectual catharsis to the very passages Plato attacked in order to prove that Homer is a teacher of self-control, not its opposite. [1] In his Prolegomena This volume provides the first English translation of the ancient scholia to Iliad books 1–2. Homer (/ ˈhoʊmər /; Ancient Greek: Ὅμηρος [hómɛːros], Hómēros; possibly born c. In that volume, we attempted to articulate the ways in which our With roots in the Homeric scholarship produced in the Library of Alexandria in the third and second centuries BCE, the ancient scholia to the Iliad constitute the richest and most extensive collection of ancient criticism on the most widely read poem in Greco-Roman antiquity. My paper addresses one area in which the scholia reveal a more nuanced criticism than their abbreviated form at first suggests, that of character (ethos) and characterization (cf. It also provides an overview of the editions available for each type of scholia and related sources. The first approach considers Euripides a (mis-) reader of Homer. Jan 1, 1997 · Homer and Writing Homer in Antiquity Homeric Papyri and Transmission of The Text Homeric Scholia The Homeric Question Oral Tradition and its Implications Neoanalysis Homer’s Dialect Homer’s Meter The Formula Homeric Style and Oral Poetics The Study of Homeric Discourse Homer and Narratology Quantifying Epic The : Structure and Interpretation None of the works on which the scholia in Venetus A are based survive. A collaborative project under the aegis of Cambridge University Press (forthcoming 2025) will enable many more readers to understand and enjoy the considerable resources found in these ancient scholarly discussions. Mar 30, 2012 · In the third essay of the volume (“The Greek origins of the Romans and the Roman Origins of Homer in the Homeric Scholia and in P. May 15, 2009 · Publication date 1855 Topics Homer -- Scholia, Homer. I enjoy reading the excerpts from the scholiasts that the commentators often cite and wonder if there are published volumes of scholia out there? The library at my local university doesn’t seem to have any, which is only fair given Oct 1, 2021 · Holy Cross undergraduates use natural language processing and word embedding to determine that Homeric Scholia are an unrooted network. The vast majority of ‘fragments’ for Aristotle’s lost Homeric Puzzles1 come from the Homeric scholia. 1-5 contain the texts in Greek, Vols. This research provides an in-depth analysis of the Homeric scholia, exploring their origins, textual transmissions, and significance within ancient Greek scholarship. Over time the scholia were copied along with the work. This is also the project team for a multi-volume English translation of the scholia vetera to the Iliad, currently accepted for publication by Cambridge University Press. Schlunk Free US Delivery | ISBN:0472087800 Better World Books (2767589) Moreover, when the Homeric scholiasts criticize Hesiod in this way, they often designate Hesiod’s ‘errors’ through technical terms, elsewhere found in the scholia when critics expressly argue against the views of other philologists, as parallels both from the Homeric scholia and other scholiastic corpora show. The translation of Homeric words into their classical or koine equivalents was a Aug 5, 2019 · Citations of Homer in the commentaries to other authors often show a clear genetic affinity with the scholia to Homer that are found at the corresponding passages of the Iliad or Odyssey. Homeric scholarship Papyrus Oxyrhynchus 221, showing scholia from Iliad XXI Homeric scholarship is the study of any Homeric topic, especially the two large surviving epics, the Iliad and Odyssey. The question […] Aug 12, 2021 · Translating the fragments of ancient exegesis to classical poets might seem to many scholars an idle task. Excerpted from lost works of ancient scholarship and transmitted as marginal and interlinear comments in medieval Dec 6, 2014 · The works from which these comments are excerpted are now lost. Richardson 272-75, Nünlist 2009 Nov 17, 2022 · The Wittenberg scholia employ several terms of the ancient scholia, especially the rhetorical terms found in the bT or “exegetical” scholia on Homer. It also contains several layers of annotations, glosses, and commentaries known as the "A scholia. Oxy. The work we describe here was completed in 2017 and analyzes eighteen books from the Homer Multitext edition of the Venetus A, comprising roughly 8,000 scholia. Annotations For the benefit of Homer scholars, we have a complete digital version of H. On the different components of the Homeric scholia and manuscripts containing them, see Erbse 1969 ‒1988, I, xi‒lix; for a survey of ancient scholarship on Homer with a discussion of how it was transmitted in the different Sep 15, 2011 · Whereas Villoison viewed the Venetus A scholia as an authoritative witness to an authoritative edition of Homer by Aristarchus, Wolf questioned the authoritativeness of the Homeric scholia and, more fundamentally, the authority of Aristarchus as an editor of Homeric poetry (see also Editions). Leaf - 1891 - The Classical Review 5 (09):412-. With a clear and accessible introduction, extensive explanatory notes, and a glossary of ancient scholars, this book serves as the ideal guide to this complex and fascinating tradition. Mar 10, 2025 · The compression and specialised language typical of Homeric scholia can be challenging even for Homeric scholars. For the later Alexandrian scholars starting with Aristarchus, whom I put into period 5 of Homeric transmission, that is, into […] Scholia Scholia are ancient commentaries, preserved in the margins of manuscripts. The case in point is Sparta in the late seventh and early sixth centuries BC in the aftermath of the Second Messenian war. Original comments are blended with extracts from earlier commentators, especially the Homeric scholia. pdf Size: 79. tumr5 65f5k didr ct 2za62 giapjh9 sien4 wei l8m6o 2ipbt